SEEKING CONSENT? THE LEGAL CHALLENGES IN CONSULTING INDIGENOUS PEOPLES FOR HYDROELECTRIC DAM PROJECTS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v33i1.1057Keywords:
Indigenous Peoples, Social Equity, Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC), Consultation, Hydroelectric DamAbstract
The consultation process with indigenous communities in large-scale development projects remains a contested issue, particularly in projects involving the relocation of the communities and compensation. This paper examines the challenges in the consultation process in the context of hydroelectric dam construction, taking the example of the Nenggiri Dam project in Malaysia which is currently under construction. Through a doctrinal legal analysis, this study argues that, with the current Malaysian legal framework recognising the customary land rights of the indigenous communities in the country, it is a legitimate expectation that the consultation process observes the principle of Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC). This is entailed from the fiduciary duty of the state authority in protecting indigenous land rights under the legal framework in Malaysia. The position of FPIC under the international legal standards, including the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) and other instruments, and its relevance to the Malaysian legal framework are also discussed. The paper further highlights gaps in the legal framework, which lacks clear mechanisms to enforce FPIC as a binding legal obligation. This paper argues for stronger legal protections and policy reforms to ensure meaningful participation of indigenous communities in decisionmaking. This could be done through formal integration of FPIC into national legislation, and the establishment of independent oversight bodies. By addressing these legal and procedural shortcomings, Malaysia can move towards a more equitable and sustainable approach in development projects affecting the indigenous peoples
Metrics
References
Aiken, S Robert, and Colin H Leigh. "Dams and Indigenous Peoples in Malaysia: Development, Displacement and Resettlement." Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 97, no. 1 (2015): 69-93.
Aishah, Humaira’, and Asmawi Ibrahim. "Land Acquisition of Indigenous Community Based on Sustainable Strategies for the Construction of the Hydro-Electric Dam Nenggiri Gua Musang Kelantan." International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences 14, no. 8 (2024): 1217-30. https://kwpublications.com/papers_submitted/11188/land-acquisition-of-indigenous-community-based-on-sustainable-strategies-for-the-construction-of-the-hydro-electric-dam-nenggiri-gua-musang-kelantan.pdf.
Bernama. "Nenggiri Hydroelectric Dam: Over 1,000 Orang Asli Affected by Construction to Be Relocated in 2026, Says Tnb." Malay Mail, 21 August 2024 2024. https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2024/08/21/nenggiri-hydroelectric-dam-over-1000-orang-asli-affected-by-construction-to-be-relocated-in-2026-says-tnb/147700.
Business Today. "Govt Ensures Orang Asli Welfare Amid Nenggiri Dam Project." April 1, 2024 2024. https://www.businesstoday.com.my/2024/04/01/govt-ensures-orang-asli-welfare-amid-nenggiri-dam-project/.
Cooke, Fadzilah Majid, Johan Nordensvard, Gusni Bin Saat, Frauke Urban, and Giuseppina Siciliano. "The Limits of Social Protection: The Case of Hydropower Dams and Indigenous Peoples' Land." Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies 4, no. 3 (2017): 437-50.
Dzulqarnain, Qistina Nadia. "Nenggiri Dam: Rm216 Mil Compensation for Orang Asli, Says Minister." The Vibes.com, 2022.https://www.thevibes.com/articles/news/67309/nenggiri-dam-rm216-mil-compensation-for-orang-asli-says-minister.
"Erica-Irene A. Daes, Final Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Indigenous Peoples: Indigenous Peoples’ Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources, 56th Sess Agenda Item 5(B) (Provisional Agenda), Un Doc E/Cn.4/Sub .2/2004/30 (13 July 2004)." http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/demo/IndigenousSovereigntyNaturalResources_Daes.pdf.
Hassan, Muhamad Sayuti, Rohaida Nordin, Izawati Wook, and Nurul Hidayat Ab Rahman. "Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (Fpic) and the Right to Self-Determination: A Case Study of Indigenous Peoples in Asean Member States, Pp. . , 2025." In Routledge Handbook of the Un Sustainable Development Goals Research and Policy, edited by Ranjula Bali Swain and Peter Dobers, 284-96: Routledge, 2025.
Ho, Peter, Nor-Hisham Bin Md Saman, and Heng Zhao. "Credibility and the Social Function of Property: A Saga of Mega-Dams, Eviction, and Privatization, as Told by Displaced Communities in Malaysia." Land 13, No. 8 (2024): 1207.". Land 13, no. 8 (2024).
Hutchinson, Terry. Researching and Writing in Law. 3rd ed. Pyrmont: Thomson Reuters, 2010.
International Hydropower Association. How-to Guide: Hydropower and Indigenous Peoples. International Hydropower Association (London, 2021).
"International Labour Organisation's (Ilo) Convention Concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples in Independent Countries 1989, Opened for Signature 28 June 1989, 1650 Unts 383 (Entered into Force 5 September 1991)."
Khir, Alla Yousra Mohamed, and Lee Liu. "Impacts of Dams on the Environment: A Review." International Journal of Environment, Agriculture and Biotechnology 6, no. 1 (2021).
Loh, Ivan. "High Court Rules in Favour of Gopeng Orang Asli Group in Hydro Dam Project Case." The Star, 9 September 2024 2024. https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2024/09/09/high-court-rules-in-favour-of-gopeng-orang-asli-group-in-hydro-dam-project-case.
Minardi, Rebecca. The Impacts on Livelihoods and Social Capital from Dam-Induced Resettlement: A Global Review. Michigan State University, 2019.
Mitchell, Terry, Courtney Arseneau, Darren Thomas, and Peggy Smith. "Towards an Indigenous-Informed Relational Approach to Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (Fpic)." International Indigenous Policy Journal 10, no. 4 (2019): 1-28. https://www.jstor.org/stable/48767144.
Montambeault, Françoise, and Martin Papillon. "Repoliticising Indigenous Participation: Fpic Protocols in Canada and Brazil." The International Journal of Human Rights 27, no. 2 (2023): 335-58.
Morgera, Elisa. "Under the Radar: The Role of Fair and Equitable Benefit-Sharing in Protecting and Realising Human Rights Connected to Natural Resources." The International Journal of Human Rights 23 (2019): 1098 - 139.
Mustaffa, Omar. "Rancangan Pengumpulan Semula (Rps) Masyarakat Orang Asli: Pencapaian Dan Cabaran (Resettlement Scheme for the Orang Asli Communities: Achievement and Challenges." In Orang Asli: Isu, Transformasi Dan Cabaran (Orang Asli: Issues, Transformation and Challenges), edited by Ma'rof Redzuan and Sarjit S. Gill. Serdang: Putra University of Malaysia, 2008.
New Straits Times. "Over 71,000 Prehistoric Artefacts Discovered, Removed in Nenggiri Valley." August 15, 2024 2024. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2024/08/1095496/over-71000-prehistoric-artefacts-discovered-removed-nenggirivalley.
Newman, Dwight. "Norms of Consultation with Indigenous Peoples: Decentralization of International Law Formation or Reinforcement of States’ Roles?", 2012.
Nicholas, Colin. Coac Comments on the Proposed Tnb-Nenggiri Dam Resettlement and Compensation Plans. Center for Orang Asli Concerns (2023).
Nordin, R., and M. S. Ibrahim. "Exercising the Principle of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (Fpic) in Land Development: An Appraisal with Special Reference to the Orang Asli in Peninsular Malaysia." Article. Pertanika Journal of Social Science and Humanities 22, no. January (2014): 183-204. http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.084942863390&partnerID=40&md5=834c755f53f48253ca06d9e81cd249e3.
Redzuan, Ma'rof, and Zahid Emby. "Orang Asli: Pembangunan Dan Ekologi Hutan (Orang Asli: Development and Forest Ecology)." Chap. 10 In Orang Asli: Isu, Transformasi Dan Cabaran (Orang Asli: Issues, Tranformasi and Challenges), edited by Ma'rof Redzuan and Sarjit
S. Gill, 204. Serdang: Putra University of Malaysia, 2008.
"Protokol Komuniti Melangkap." 2019, https://sabc.sabah.gov.my/sites/default/files/uploads/attachments/2019-11/Protokol-Komuniti-Melangkap.pdf.
Schapper, Andrea, and Frauke Urban. " Large Dams, Norms and Indigenous Peoples." Development Policy Review 39 (2021): 061-80.
Tignino, Mara, and Diego Jara. "Human Rights Law in the Development of Hydropower Projects in Transboundary Context." Frontiers in Climate 6 (2024).
United Nations. Paris Agreement (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change) (2015). https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/english_paris_agreement.pdf.
"United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, Ga Res 61/295, Un Gaor, 61st Sess, Agenda Item 68, Un Doc a/Res/61/295, Adopted 13 September 2007." 2007.
Walsh, Bryan. "Want More Clean Energy Projects? Give Communities a Stake." Time, June 27, 2024 2024. https://time.com/6992183/clean-energy-canada-community-ownership/.
Ward, Tara. "The Right to Free, Prior and Informed Consent: Indigenous Peoples' Participation Rights within International Law." Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights 10, no. 2 (2011): 54-84.
World Commission on Dams. Dams and Development: A New Framework for Decision-Making. (London: Earthscan, 2000). https://awsassets.panda.org/downloads/wcd_dams_final_report.pdf.
Yun, Tan Zhai. "Social: A Blind Spot in the Transition?" The Edge Malaysia, 2024, June 17 2024. https://theedgemalaysia.com/node/715527.
Yusoff, Ronzi Mohd, Sharina Abdul Halim, and Joy Jacqueline Pereira. "Impak Pembinaan Empangan Temenggor Ke Atas Sosioekonomi Komuniti Orang Asli Jahai Di Rancangan Pengumpulan Semula Air Banun, Perak." Asian People Journal (APJ) 5, no. 1 (2022): 85-100.
Zarri, Liam J, Eric P. Palkovacs, David M. Post, Nina O. Therkildsen, and Alexander S. Flecker. " The Evolutionary Consequences of Dams and Other Barriers for Riverine Fishes." BioScience 72, no. 5 (2022): 431-48.
Zurba, Melanie, and Anastasia Papadopoulos. "Indigenous Participation and the Incorporation of Indigenous Knowledge and Perspectives in Global Environmental Governance Forums: A Systematic Review." Environmental Management 72, no. 1 (2023): 84-99.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
© Copyright 1993-2024 IIUM Press
The IIUM Law Journal is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
- Consent to publish: The Author(s) undertakes that the article named above is original and consents that the IIUM Press publishes it.
- Previous publication: The Author(s) guarantees that the article named above has not been published before in any form, that it is not concurrently submitted to another publication, and that it does not infringe anyone’s copyright. The Author(s) holds the IIUM Press and Editors of IIUM Law Journal harmless against all copyright claims.
- Transfer of copyright: The Author(s) hereby transfers the copyright of the article to the IIUM Press, which shall have the exclusive and unlimited right to publish the article in any form, including on electronic media. The Journal in turn grants the Author(s) the right to reproduce the article for educational and scientific purposes, provided the written consent of the Publisher is obtained.
