إِشكَالِيةُ العَقْلِ الحَدَاثِيِّ في بِناءِ المَعرفةِ الدِّينيةِ قراءة تحليلية لآراء عبدالكريم سروش (The Problem of The Modernist Mind In Constructing Religious Knowledge: An Analytical Reading of The Opinions of Abdul Karim Soroush)

Authors

  • نشوان عبده خالد .أستاذ مساعد في قسم دراسات القرآن والسنة بالجامعة الإسلامية العالمية بماليزيا
  • يونس البقالي .طالب ماجستير بالجامعة الإسلامية العالمية بماليزيا

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31436/jia.v18i3.1076

Keywords:

الكلمات المفتاحية: العقل – الحداثة – الفكر الإسلامي

Abstract

يهدف هذا البحث إلى تسليط الضوء على قراءة عبد الكريم سروش لمفهوم العقل ودوره في بناء المعرفة الدينية، حيث ذهب أن الغاية منه هو البحث والتقصي فقط وليس الوصول إلى الحق والحقيقة، وزعم أن حدود عمل العقل مطلقة لا حدود لها، وأن مخرجاته تتسم في النهاية بالنسبية إذ يصعب الوصول إلى الحقيقة وفهم الخطاب بحسب وجهة نظره، ومن أبرز نتائج هذه القراءة أن رؤية سروش هذه تؤدي إلى تقويض مفهوم العقل وإسقاط حجيته ودوره في تشكيل المعرفة الدينية ذلك لأنها جعلته في مصافِّ النسبية، وعملت على الإخلال بغرضه.

الكلمات المفتاحية: العقل، الحداثة، الفكر الإسلامي، عبد الكريم سروش.

Abstract

This research aims to highlight Abd al-Karim Soroush’s reading of the concept of reason and its role in building religious knowledge, where the goal is to research and investigate only and not to reach the facts and truth, as he claimed that the limits of mind ability are absolute, and that its outputs are in the end relative, as it is difficult to reach the truth and understand the discourse according to his point of view. The most important result of this reading is that Soroush's vision of the concept of reason leads to undermining this concept and dropping its authority and role in shaping religious knowledge, because it placed it in the ranks of relativism, and worked to violate its purpose.

Keywords: Reason, Modernity, Islamic thought, Abdolkarim

References

Abū Ya᾿alᾱ, Muhammad bin Hussein. (1990 A.D). al ᾿Uddat fī Usūl al Fiqh. (2nd edition). Ahmad bin ᾿Alī bin Sayr al Mubᾱrakī (review). Riyadh: Muhammad ibn Saud University.

Al ᾿Abbᾱdī, ᾿Alī Ḥamūd. (2009 A.D). Falsafat al Dīn. (1st edition). Beirut: Dᾱa Jawwᾱd.

Al Bukhᾱrī, Abū ᾿Abdillah bin Ismᾱ᾿īl. (1422 A.D). Ṣaḥīḥ al Bukhᾱrī. (1st edition). Beirut: Dᾱr Tawq al Najᾱh.

Al Dhazᾱlī, ‛Abū Ḥᾱmid. (1975 A.D). Mu᾿ᾱlij al Qudus fī Madᾱriji Ma᾿arifat al Nafs. (2nd edition). Dᾱr al ‛Ᾱfᾱq al Jadīdah.

Al Ghazᾱlī, ‛Abū Ḥᾱmid bin Muhammad. (1967 A.D). Al Munqidh min Al Ḍalᾱl Wa al Mūṣil ‛ilᾱ dhī al Ḥujjat Wa al Jalᾱl. (7th edition). Beirut: Dᾱr al Andalus.

Al Ghazᾱlī, ‛Abū Ḥᾱmid bin Muhammad. (2004). ‛Iḥyᾱ‛u ᾿Ulūm al Dīn. (1st edition). Beirut: Dᾱr al Kutub al ᾿Ilmiyyah.

Al Juwainī, ᾿Abd al Malik bin ᾿Abdillah. (1997 A.D). al Burhᾱn fī ‛Usūl al Fiqh. (1st edition). Ṣalᾱḥ bin Muhammad bin ᾿Uwaiḍah (review). Beirut: Dᾱr al Kutub al ᾿Ilmiyyah.

Al Kharᾱshī, Sulaiman Ṣᾱliḥ. (no date). Naqḍ ‛Usūl al ᾿Aqlᾱniyyīn. (1st edition). Riyadh: Dᾱr ᾿Ulūm al Sunnah.

Al Kīlᾱnī, Mᾱjid ᾿Arsᾱn. (1987 A.D). Falsafat At Tarbiyat al ‛Islᾱmiyyah: Dirᾱsatun Muqᾱranatun bayna Falsafat al Tarbiyat al ‛Islᾱmiyyah Wa al Falsafᾱt al Tarbawiyyat al Mu᾿ᾱṣirah. (1st edition). Saudi Arabia: Maktabat al Manᾱrah.

Al Muḥᾱsibī, al Ḥᾱrith bin ‛Asad. (1971 A.D). Al ᾿Aql Wa Fahm al Qur‛ᾱn. (1st edition). Beirut: Dᾱr al Fikr.

Al Ra᾿awᾱsh, ᾿Imᾱd, (no date). Al ᾿Aql Wa ‛Atharuhu fī al Tafsīr. (1st edition). Saudi Arabia: Muhammad ibn Saud University.

Al Shᾱṭibī, Abū ‛Ishᾱq al Lakhmī. (1997 A.D). Al Muwᾱfaqᾱt. (1st edition). Riyadh: Dᾱr Ibn ᾿Affᾱn.

Al Turkī, ᾿Abdullah bin ᾿Abd al Muḥsin. (1417 A.D). Mujmal I᾿tiqᾱd ‛A‛immat al Salaf. (2nd edition). Saudi Arabia: Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Da᾿awah and Guidance.

Ḍamīriyyah, ᾿Uthmᾱn Jumu᾿ah. (1996 A.D). Madkhal li Al Dirᾱsat al ᾿Aqīdat al ‛Islᾱmiyyah. (2nd edition). Riyadh: Maktabat al Sawᾱdī li al Tawzī᾿.

Ibn Khaldūn, ᾿Abdul Al Rahmᾱn. (1988 A.D). Dīwᾱn al Mubtada‛ Wa al Khabar fī Ta‛rīkh al ᾿Arab Wa al Barbar Wa man ᾿ᾱṣarahum min dhawī al Sha‛an al ‛Akbar. (2nd edition). Beirut: Dᾱr al Fikr.

Ibn Taimiyyah, Ahmad ᾿Abdul al Ḥalīm al Ḥarbī. (1403 A.H). al Istiqᾱmah. (1st edition). Muhammad Rashᾱd Sᾱlim (Review). Al Madīnat al Munawwarah: Muhammad ibn Saud University.

Ibn Taimiyyah, Ahmad ᾿Abdul al Ḥalīm al Ḥarbī. (1999 A.D). Dar‛u Ta᾿ᾱruḍ al Naql Wa al ᾿Aql. (2nd edition). Saudi Arabia: Muhammad ibn Saud University.

Ismᾱ᾿īl, Fᾱṭimah Ismᾱ᾿īl Muhammad. (1993 A.D). al Qur‛ᾱn Wa al Naẓar al ᾿Aqlī. (1st edition). USA: Virginia.

Ja᾿afarī, Muhammad. (2010 A.D). al ᾿Aql Wa al Dīn fī Tasawwurᾱt al Mustanīrīn al Dīniyyīn al Mu᾿ᾱsirīn. (2nd edition). Ḥaidar Najif (translation). Beirut: Markaz al Ḥaḍᾱrat al Fikr al ‛Islᾱmī.

Khalīl, ᾿Imᾱd al Dīn. (1403 A.D). Ḥawla ‛I᾿ᾱdat Tashkīl al ᾿Aql al Salīm. (2nd edition). Qatar: Ri‛ᾱsat al Maḥᾱkim al Shar᾿iyyah Wa al Shu‛ūn al Dīniyyah.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Ḥakīm et al. (2009 A.D). Al Fiqr al Dīnī Wa Taḥaddiyᾱt al Ḥadᾱthah. (1st edition). Ahmad al Qabanjī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2002 A.D). Al Qabḍ Wa al Basṭ fī al Sharī᾿ah. (1st edition). Dalᾱl ᾿Abbᾱs (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al Jadīd.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2009 A.D). Al Dīn Al ᾿almᾱnī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2009 A.D). Al Ṣirᾱṭᾱt al Mustaqīmah: Qirᾱ‛atun Jadīdatun li al Naẓariyyat al Ta᾿addudiyyat al Dīniyyah. (1st edition). Ahmad al Qabbanjī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2009 A.D). Al Turᾱth Wa al ᾿almᾱniyah. (1st edition). Ahmad al Qabbanī (review). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2009 A.D). Basṭ al Tajribat al Nabawiyyah (translation): Ahmad al Qabbanjī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2010 A.D). Al ᾿Aql Wa al Ḥurriyyah. (1st edition). Ahmad al Qabbanjī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm. (2014 A.D). Arḥab Min al ‛īdiyūlūjiyᾱ. (1st edition). Ahmad al Qabbanjī (translation). Beirut: Dᾱr al ‛Intishᾱr al ᾿Arabī.

ELECTRONIC SOURCES:

Sarūsh, ᾿Abdul Karīm, Al Sīrat al Dhᾱtiyyah. http://drsoroush.com/en/biography. Accessed on 6th December, 2021 A.D.

Downloads

Published

2021-12-31

How to Cite

عبده خالد ن., & البقالي ي. . (2021). إِشكَالِيةُ العَقْلِ الحَدَاثِيِّ في بِناءِ المَعرفةِ الدِّينيةِ قراءة تحليلية لآراء عبدالكريم سروش (The Problem of The Modernist Mind In Constructing Religious Knowledge: An Analytical Reading of The Opinions of Abdul Karim Soroush). Journal of Islam in Asia (E-ISSN 2289-8077), 18(3), 69–94. https://doi.org/10.31436/jia.v18i3.1076

Issue

Section

Arabic Articles