DEATH PENALTY AND RIDDAH: A CRITICAL EVALUATION TOWARDS THE CLAIM OF A JURISTIC IJMĀ‘
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v31i2.886Keywords:
Islamic Criminal Law, Ijmā‘, ApostasyAbstract
Contemporary academics and ‘ulama debate back and forth regarding whether Islam really supports the execution of those who have apostatised away from Islam (i.e. committed riddah). There is already numerous research dedicated to the interpretation of verses of the Qur’an and aḥadīth relevant to riddah, and what legal rulings can be derived from them. What often alludes contemporary academics is what some ‘ulama call the “third primary source of Islamic law”, namely ijmā‘. Claims of and counterclaims against ijmā‘ regarding executing the murtadin have often been cited in passing, somehow the latter more lengthily explained. What is missing, however, is a comprehensive analysis of these ijmā‘ claims and counterclaims and this is what our research does. Through literature research using comparative fiqh analysis, we critically examine whether an ijmā‘ has been achieved during the era of the Salaf al-Ṣāliḥ (pious predecessors) then the classical madhāhib regarding the matter of murtadin execution, considering also potential exceptions. Finding the affirmative, we critically analyse what to make of the contemporary dissenting opinions in navigating the present-day challenges to implement Islamic criminal law.
Metrics
References
Abī Shaybah, Muḥammad, ‘Abd Allah and Muṣannaf Ibn Abī Shaybah, vol. 6 (Riyadh: Maktabah al-Rushd, 1409), no. 32729.
‘Abd Allah ibn Muḥammad Ibn Abī Shaybah, Muṣannaf Ibn Abī Shaybah, vol. 5 (Riyadh: Maktabah Al-Rushd, 1409), no. 30928.
‘Abd al-Razzāq Al-Ṣan‘ānī, Al-Muṣannaf, vol. 10 (India: Majlis al-‘Ilmi, 1983), no. 18714.
‘Alī ibn ‘Umar Al-Dāraquṭnī, Sunan Al-Dāraquṭnī, vol. 4 (Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risalah, 2004), no. 3211.
‘Alā al-Dīn Al-Kāsānī, Badā’i‘ Al-Ṣanā‘I‘, vol. 7 (Beirut: Dar al-Kutub ’Ilmiyyah, 1328), 134.
‘Ali Muhammad As-Sallabi, The Biography of Abu Bakr As-Siddeeq (Riyadh: Darussalam, n.d.), 353.
’Alī ibn Sulaimān Al-Mardāwī, Al-Inṣāf Fi Ma‘rifat Rājiḥ Min Khilāf (Bayt al-Fikar al-Dawilyyah, 2004), 1775.
ʿAbd Allāh b. Aḥmad ibn Qudāmah Al-Maqdīsī, Al-Mughni, vol. 12 (Riyadh: Dar ’Alam al-Kutub Lil Tiba’ah, 1997), 264.
ʿAbd al-Wahhāb ibn Aḥmad Al-Shaʿrānī, Al-Mīzān Al-Kubra, vol. 3 (Damascus: Dār al-Taqwā, 2022), 377.
Abu al-Walīd Al-Bājī Al-Mālikī, Al-Muntaqa Sharḥ Al-Muwaṭṭa, vol. 5 (Cairo: Mathba’ah al-Sa’adah, 1332), 281–82.
Abu Bakr Aḥmad Ibn al-Ḥusayn Al-Bayhaqi, Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, vol. 17 (Cairo: Markaz Hajr Lilbuḥūth wal Dirāsat al-‘Arabiyyah wa al-
Islamiyyah, 2004), no. 16833.
Abū Ḥāmid Muḥammad Al-Ghazālī, Al-Muṣtaṣfa Min ‘Ilm Al-Uṣūl (Beirut: Dar al-Kutub ’Ilmiyyah, 1993), 374–75.
Abū Ḥafṣ ʿUmar Ibn ʿAlī Ibn Al-Mulaqqin, Khulaṣah Al-Badr Al-Munīr, vol. 2 (Maktabah Al-Rushd, 1989), 298.
Abu Umar ibn al-Husayn Khiraqi, The Mukhtasar of Al-Khiraqi, trans. Anas Khalid (New York: New York University, 1992), 234.
Aḥmad ibn `Abd al-Ḥalīm Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Ṣārim Al-Maslūl ‘Ala Shātim Al-Rasūl (Saudi Arabia: Al-Haras Al-Waṭāni Al-Su‘ūdi, n.d.), 313–20.
Aḥmad ibn ’Abdulrazaq Al-Duwayshi, ed., Fatāwā Al-Lajnah Al-Dāʾimah Li Al-Buḥūth Al-ʿIlmiyya Wa Al-Iftā, vol. 1 (Riyadh: Dar al-Mu’ayyad, 2003), 401.
Ahmad Mohamed Ibrahim, The Administration of Islamic Law in Malaysia (Kuala Lumpur: Institute of Islamic Understanding Malaysia, 2000), 593–95.
ʿAlī ibn Aḥmad ibn Saʿīd ibn Ḥazm, Al-Muhallā Bi Al-Āthār, vol. 12 (Beirut: Dār al-Fikr, n.d.), 108–13.
ʿAlī ibn Aḥmad ibn Saʿīd ibn Ḥazm, Marātib Al-Ijmā‘ (Dār ibn Ḥazm, 1998), 210.
al-Khaṭīb Aḥmad ibn ʿAlī al-Shāfiʿī Al-Baghdādī, Uṣūl Al-Dīn (Beirut: Dar al-Kutub ’Ilmiyyah, 2002), 213.
Anghie, Antony. “International Human Rights Law and a Developing World Perspective,” in Routledge Handbook of International
Human Rights Law, ed. Scot Sheeran and Sir Nigel Rodley. New York: Routledge, 2013.
Badr ad-Dīn Muḥammad Al-Zarkashī, Al-Baḥr Al-Muḥīṭ, vol. 6 (Kuwait City: Dar al-Kutubi, 1994), 456.
Badr ad-Dīn Muḥammad Al-Zarkashī, Tashnīf Al-Masāmi’, vol. 3 (Makkah: Maktabah Al-Makiyyah, 1998), 137.
Burhān al-Dīn Al-Marghīnānī, Al-Hidāyah Fī Sharḥ Bidāyat Al-Mubtadī, vol. 4 (Karachi: Idarah al-Qur’an wa al-‘Ulum al-Islamiyyah, 1417), 330–31.
Muhammadin, Fajri Matahati and Shania Dwini Azzahra, “The Role of Fiqh Al-Siyar in International Law-Making: Escaping the Lethargy,”
Al-Jami’ah: Journal of Islamic Studies 60, no. 2 (2022): 509–46.
Ḥamūd Al-Ruḥayli, Al-‘Alamaniyyah Wa Mawqif Al-Islām Minhā (Madinah: Madinah International University, 1422), 396.
Mehat, Hashim. Malaysian Law & Islamic Law on Sentencing. Kuala Lumpur: International Law Book Services, 1991. 207.
Ibn Ḥajar Al-ʿAsqalānī, Fatḥ Al-Bārī Bi Sharḥ Al-Bukhārī, vol. 1 (Cairo: Al-Maktabah Al-Salafiyyah, 1390), 13.
Ibn Qudamah Al-Maqdisi, Al-Mughni, vol. 12 (Dar ‘Alam al-Kutub al-Tiba‘ah wa al-Nasr Wa al-Tawzi‘, 1997), 264.
Ibrahim Salama and Michael Wiener, Reconciling Religion and Human Rights: Faith in Multilateralism (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2022), 37
Ibrahim Salama and Michael Wiener, “‘Faith for Rights’ in Armed Conflict: Lessons from Practice,” Journal of Human Rights Practice 20 (2023): 11.
‘Iyāḍ bin Mūsa, Ikmāl Al-Mu‘Alim Bifawā’Id Muslim, vol. 6 (Dar al-Wafa Lil Ṭiba‘ah wa al-Nashr wa al-Tawzi‘, 1998), 223.
Dolinger, Jacob. “The Failure of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,” The University of Miami Inter-American Law Review 47, no. 2 (2016): 191.
Jalāl al-Dīn al-Khuḍayrī Al-Suyūṭī, Al-Ashbāh Wa Al-Nazhā’ir (Beirut: Dar al-Kutub ’Ilmiyyah, 1983), 101–2.
Mahmūd Al-Ṭahhān, Taysīr Muṣṭalaḥ Al-Ḥadīth (Maktabah Al-Ma‘arif Lil Nashr wa al-Tawzi‘, 2004), 85; Ṭāhir ibn Ṣāliḥ Al-Jazayri, Tawjīh Al-Nazhr Ilā Uṣūl Al-Athar, vol. 2 (Aleppo: Maktabah Al-Maṭbū‘ah Al-Islāmiyyah, 1995), 229.
Nagata, Masaki. “The Radical Nation-State and Contemporary Extremism,” Middle East Law and Governance 11, no. 3 (2019): 319–45.
Mohamed S. El-Awa, Punishment in Islamic Law: A Comparative Study (Indianapolis: American Trust Publications, 1982), 55.
Kamali, Mohammad Hashim. Crime and Punishment in Islamic Law: A Fresh Interpretation (Oxford University Press, 2019), 141–47.
Mohd Kamal, Mohd Hisham. “Kebebasan Beragama Dan Isu Riddah Dari Perspektif Syariah,” in Isu-Isu Kebebasan Beragama &
Penguatkuasaan Undang-Undang Moral, ed. Mohd Hisham Mohd Kamal and Shamrahayu A. Aziz (Selangor Darul Ehsan: Department of Islamic Law IIUM & Harun M. Hashim Law Centre, 2009).
Muḥammad ibn Jarīr Al-Ṭabari, Jāmi‘ Al-Bayān ‘An Ta’Wīl Āyat Al-Qur’An, vol. 9 (Makkah: Dar al-Tarbih wa al-Turath, n.d.), 318
Muhammad Abu Zahrah, Al-Jarīmah Wa Al-’Uqubat Fī Al-Fiqh Al-Islami (Cairo: Dar al-Fikr Al-‘Arabi, 1998), 157–58.
Muḥammad ibn ‘Alī Al-Shawkānī, Irshād Al-Fuḥūl, vol. 2 (Beirut: Dar al-Kitab Al-‘Arabi, 1999), 278.
Muḥammad ibn ‘Alī Al-Shawkānī, Nayl Al-Awṭār, vol. 7 (Egypt: Dar al-Hadith, 1993), 226.
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad ibn Abi Sahl Al-Sarakhsī, Al-Mabsūṭ Fī Al-Fiqh, vol. 10 (Beirut: Dar al-Ma’rifah, n.d.), 110.
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad ibn Abi Sahl Al-Sarakhsī, Sharḥ Al-Siyār Al-Kabīr (Egypt: Al-Shirkah al-Sharqiyyah li l-I‘lānāt, 1971), 1939.
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad ibn Rushd, Bidāyat Al-Mujtahid Wa Nihayat Al-Muqtaṣid, vol. 4 (Cairo: Maktabah Ibn Taymiyyah, 1415), 426.
Muḥammad ibn Ibrāhīm ibn Al-Mundhir, Al-Ijmā‘ (Cairo: Dar al-Athar lil Nasr wa al-Tawzi‘, n.d.), 133.
Muḥammad ibn ʿĪsā al-Sulamī Al-Tirmidhī, Jami Al-Tirmidhi, vol. 3 (Riyadh: Darussalam, 2007), hadith no. 1458.
Muḥammad ibn Ismā‘īl Al-Bukhārī, Sahih Al-Bukhari, vol. 9 (Riyadh: Darussalam, 1997), Hadith no. 6922.
Muḥammad ibn Ṣāliḥ Al-‘Uthaymīn, Muṣṭalah Al-Ḥadīth (Cairo: Maktabah Al-’Ilm, 1994), 49; Yaḥya ibn Sharaf Al-Nawawī, Al-Arba‘īn Al-Nawawiyyah (Beirut: Dar Al-Minhaj, 2009), 49.
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad ibn ʿUthmān Ibn Al-Dhahabī, Siyar A‘Lām Al-Nubalā,’ vol. 4 (Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risalah, 1422), 110; Al-Sarakhsī, Al-Mabsūṭ, 10:111.
Muḥammad ibn Ḥumūd Al-Wā’ilī, Bughayat Al-Muqtaṣid Sharḥ Bidāyat Al-Mujtahid, vol. 16 (Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm, 1440), 9919.
Muḥammad Nāṣiruddīn Al-Albānī, Silsilah Al-Ḍā‘Ifah, vol. 7 (Riyadh: Dar al-Ma’arif, 1412), 291–92.
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad Al-Qurṭubī, Al-Jāmi’ Li Aḥkām Al-Qur’ān, vol. 6 (Cairo: Dar al-Kutub Al-Misriyyah, 1964), 158.
Mūsá ibn Aḥmad Al-Ḥajjāwī, Al-Iqnā‘ Al-Ṭālib Al-Intifā‘, vol. 4 (Darah Al-Malik ‘Abd al-‘Aziz, 2002), 291.
Muḥmaṣṣānī, Arkān Ḥuqūq Al-Insān; Kamali, Crime and Punishment; Ibrahim, The Administration of Islamic Law in Malaysia; El-Awa, Punishment.
Mohsen Al Attar, “Reframing the ‘Universality’ of International Law in a Globalizing World,” McGill Law Journal 59, no. 1 (2013): 95–139.
Mohamed Azam Mohamed Adil, “Syariah Criminal Code (II) Enactment 1993 Amendment 2015: Can Kelantan Enforce Hudud?,” ICR Journal 7, no. 4 (2016): 548–51.
Muḥammad ibn Ṣāliḥ Al-‘Uthaymīn, Uṣūl Fī Tafsīr (Al-Maktabah Al-Islamiyyah, 2001), 16–17.
Najm ad-Dīn Sulaymān ibn ʿAbd al-Qawī Al-Ṭūfī, Sharḥ Mukhtaṣar Al-Rawḍah, vol. 3 (Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Risalah, 1987), 83.
Naz Khatoon Modirzadeh, “‘[L]et Us All Agree To Die A Little’: TWAIL’s Unfulfilled Promise,” Harvard International Law Journal (Upcoming) 65 (2023): 1–67.
Nesrine Badawi, “Regulation of Armed Conflict: Critical Comparativism,” Third World Quarterly 37, no. 11 (2016): 1990–2009.
Sayf al- Dīn Al-Āmidī, Al-Iḥkām Fî Uṣūl Al-Aḥkām, vol. 1 (Beirut: Maktab al-Islami, 1402), 252.
Sayyid Sabiq, Fikih Sunnah, ed. Muḥammad Nāṣiruddīn Al-Albānī (tahqiq and takhrij), vol. 3 (Jakarta: Cakrawala Publishing, 2009), 334.
Ṣubḥī Muḥmaṣṣānī, Arkān Ḥuqūq Al-Insān (Beirut: Dār al-ʿIlm li- l’Malayīn, 1979), 123–124.
Syed Muhammad Naquib Al-Attas, Risalah Untuk Kaum Muslimin (Kuala Lumpur: ISTAC, 2001).
‘Uthmān bin ‘ Alī Ḥasan, Manhaj Al-Istidlal ‘Alā Al-I‘tiqād ‘Inda Ahl Al-Sunnah Wa Al-Jamā‘Ah (al-Riyāḍ: Maktabah Ar-Rushd, 1415), 149–
Wahbah al-Zuḥaylī, Fiqih Islam Wa Al-Adillatuhu, vol. 1 (Jakarta: Gema Insani Press, 2011), 72–76; Aḥmad ibn `Abd al-Ḥalīm Ibn
Taymiyyah, Raf’ Al-Malām ‘an Al-Aimmat Al-A‘Lām (Riyadh: Dār al-Iftā’, 1413), 9.
Wahbah Al-Zuḥaylī, Fiqih Islam Wa Al-Adillatuhu, vol. 3 (Jakarta: Gema Insani Press, 2011), 50–60.
Wahbah al-Zuḥaylī, Uṣūl Al-Fiqh Al-Islāmī (Damascus: Dar al-Fikr, 1986), 1139–40.
Yaḥya ibn Sharaf Al-Nawawī, Al-Minhaj Sharḥ Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, vol. 12 (Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-’Arabi, 1392), 208.
Yaḥyā’ ibn Abi al-Khayr Al-Umrani, Al-Bayān Fi Madhhab Imām Al-Shāfi‘Ī, vol. 12 (Jeddah: Dar al-Minhaj, n.d.), 48.
Yūsuf Al-Qaraḍāwi, Fi Fiqh Al-Awlawiyat (Maktab al-Islami, 1999).
Yūsuf Ibn ‘Abd Allah ibn ‘Abd Al-Barr, Al-Tamhīd, vol. 3 (London: Mu’assasah al-Furqan, 2017), 707.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
- Consent to publish: The Author(s) undertakes that the article named above is original and consents that the IIUM Press publishes it.
- Previous publication: The Author(s) guarantees that the article named above has not been published before in any form, that it is not concurrently submitted to another publication, and that it does not infringe anyone’s copyright. The Author(s) holds the IIUM Press and Editors of IIUM Law Journal harmless against all copyright claims.
- Transfer of copyright: The Author(s) hereby transfers the copyright of the article to the IIUM Press, which shall have the exclusive and unlimited right to publish the article in any form, including on electronic media. The Journal in turn grants the Author(s) the right to reproduce the article for educational and scientific purposes, provided the written consent of the Publisher is obtained.
