THE ORIGINS OF THE TRUST DOCTRINE FOR THE INDIGENOUS PEOPLES: A COMMENTARY FROM THE MALAYSIAN PERSPECTIVE

Asril Amirul Zakariah; Wan Izatul Asma Wan Talaat; Murshamshul Kamariah Musa; Mohd Shahril Nizam Md Radzi

doi:10.31436/iiumlj.v31iS1.880

Authors

Asril Amirul Zakariah
Wan Izatul Asma Wan Talaat
Murshamshul Kamariah Musa
Mohd Shahril Nizam Md Radzi

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v31iS1.880

Keywords:

Legal History, Indigenous Peoples, Trust Doctrine, Aboriginal Peoples Act 1954, UNDRIP

Abstract

The Trust Doctrine governs the fiduciary relationship between the state and indigenous peoples, in which the state acts as a trustee for the benefit of its indigenous peoples. However, many states have failed to fulfil their duty and have acted oppressively towards the indigenous peoples. This study critically examines the background and origins of the Trust Doctrine from the United States, its practical application in the state-indigenous relationship, and the efforts made towards a positive translation of the doctrine. In addition, the study explores the impact of a positive implementation of the Trust Doctrine in Malaysia and on the international stage, particularly in the context of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). By analysing the Trust Doctrine's origins, application, and impact, this study highlights the challenges and opportunities for the rights of indigenous peoples (Orang Asli) in Malaysia and beyond. The study emphasises the significance of transforming the Trust Doctrine into a meaningful tool for promoting and protecting the rights of indigenous peoples, while also recognising its potential for environmental protection. Ultimately, this study contributes to the ongoing global discussion on the rights of indigenous peoples and the need for more effective state-indigenous relations. The research methodology employed in this study involves a doctrinal legal research approach and utilises the content analysis method to gather perspectives from the international context and apply them to the Malaysian context.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Aberle, David F. "The Navajo-Hopi Land Dispute and Navajo Relocation," Anthropological Approaches to Resettlement Policy, Practice, And Theory, ed. Michael Cernea and Scott Guggenheim ( Routledge, 2019), 153-200.

Archambault, David. "The Standing Rock Protests and the Struggle for Tribal Sovereignty," Journal of International Affairs 73.2 (2020): 233-238.

Cave, Alfred. “Abuse of Power: Andrew Jackson and the Indian Removal Act of 1830,”The Historian” 65, no. 6 (2003): 1330-1353.

Cobo, Jose Martinez. “Study of the Problem of Discrimination Against Indigenous Populations,” UN Doc E/CN.4/Sub.2/1986/7 and Add.1-4.

Colonialism is a practice of domination, which involves the subjugation of one people to another. Margaret Kohn and Edward N. Zalta (eds), “Colonialism”, The Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (Summer 2010 Edition), accessed May 1, 2023, http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2010/entries/colonialism/.

Daes, Erica Irene A. “Working Paper by The Chairperson Rapporteur Of The United Nations Working Group On Indigenous Populations,” UN Doc E/CN.4/Sub.2/AC.4/1996/2.

Fredericks, John. "America's First Nations: the origins, history and future of American Indian Sovereignty." Journal of Law & Policy 7 (1998): 347

Hamid, Zakri Abdul. (Ed.), Prospects in Biodiversity Prospecting (Bangi: Genetics Society of Malaysia, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, 1995), 225-265.

Hamid, Abdul Ghafur. “The Principle That the Land Dominates the Sea in The Context of South China Sea Disputes: A Critical Appraisal,” IIUM Law Journal 30, no. 2 (2022): 49–75, https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v30i2.742.

Hassan, Daud. "The Rise of the Territorial State and The Treaty of Westphalia,”Yearbook of New Zealand Jurisprudence 9 (2006): 62-70.

Hassan, Muhamad Sayuti. and Nordin, Rohaida. "Political Participation of Aboriginal People (Orang Asli) in Peninsular Malaysia: Examining the Compatibility of the Aboriginal Peoples Act 1954 with UNDRIP Standards," International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 28.3 (2020): 493-513

Idrus, Rusaslina. "The Discourse of Protection and The Orang Asli in Malaysia," Kajian Malaysia: Journal of Malaysian Studies 29 (2011).

Josephy, Alvin M., Nagel, Joane and Johnson, Troy. Red Power: American Indians Fight for Freedom (Nebraska, University of Nebraska Press, 1999), 6.

Kelly, Lawrence C. “The Indian Reorganization Act: The Dream and the Reality," Pacific Historical Review 44.3 (1975): 291-312.

Kothari, Ashish. "Traditional Knowledge And Sustainable Development." International Institute for Sustainable Development (2007).

Latiff, Abdul and Hamid, Zakri. “Biodiversity and Traditional Knowledge? The Malaysian Experience,” in Protecting and Promoting Traditional Knowledge: Systems, National Experiences and International Dimensions,eds. Sophia Twarog and Promila Kapoor, (New York and Geneva: United Nations: 2004).

Marimuthu, Siva Barathi and Zakariah, Asril Amirul. “The Sufficiency of Malaysia’s Environmental Laws for the Protection of the Tasik Chini UNESCO Biosphere Reserve,” Australian Journal of Asian Law 21 (2020): 25-37.

McLaughlin, James. My Friend the Indian (Boston: Houghton and Mifflin, 1910).

Olson, James. "All Aboard: Navigating the Course for Universal Adoption of the Public Trust Doctrine," Vermont Journal of Environmental Law. 15 (2013): 135.

Pitty, Roderic and Smith, Shannara. "The Indigenous Challenge To Westphalian Sovereignty," Australian Journal of Political Science 46.1 (2011): 121-139

Prucha, Francis P. The Indians in American Society: From the Revolutionary War to the Present (Berkeley, University of California Press, 1985), 101.

Ragavan, Srividya. “Protection of Traditional Knowledge,”Minnesota Intellectual Property Law Review 2, no. 2 (2001).

Rights, Shinnecock. “How the Federal Government Is Failing to Protect Indigenous Sovereignty from State Judicial Infringement," Cardozo J. Equal Rts. & Soc. Just. 29 (2022): 195; Evan Fox-Decent, "Fashioning Legal Authority from power: The Crown-native Fiduciary Relationship." New Zealand Journal of Public & International Law 4 (2006): 91.

Rosser, Ezra. "The Trade-Off Between Self-Determination and the Trust Doctrine: Tribal Government and The Possibility Of Failure," Ark. L. Rev. 58 (2005): 291.

Saleem, Muhammad Yusuf. "Environmental Issues In A Federation: The Case of Malaysia," Intellectual Discourse IIUM 13.2 (2005).

Stavenhagen, Rodolfo. “Report Of The Special Rapporteur On The Situation Of Human Rights And Fundamental Freedoms of Indigenous People,” A/HRC/4/32, Human Rights Council, 2007.

Sulaiman, Noor Atiqah. “Orang Asli Tetap Pilihan Utama Jawat Ketua Pengarah JAKOA,” Harian Metro, May 19, 2021, https://www.hmetro.com.my/mutakhir/2021/05/707692/orang-asli-tetap-pilihan-utama-jawat-ketua-pengarah-jakoa.

The International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs (IWGIA),accessed May 1, 2023, http://www.iwgia.org/images/stories/sections/regions/asia/documents/IW2013/Malaysia.pdf.

Wilkins, David E. "‘With The Greatest Respect and Fidelity:’ a Cherokee Vision of the ‘Trust’ doctrine," The Social Science Journal34.4 (1997): 495-510.

Wilkins, David E. and Lomawaima, K. Tsianina Uneven Ground: American Indian Sovereignty and Federal Law (Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, 2001), 66.

Wilkinson, Charles F and Biggs, Eric R. "The Evolution of the Termination Policy," American Indian Law Review 5.1 (1977): 139-184

Wilkinson, David Charles and Williams, Robert. Cases and Materials on Federal Indian Law, 5th ed. (St. Paul: Thomson-West, 2005), 342.

Wook, Izawati. “Indigenous Land Disputes and Law Reform in India: Lessons for Malaysia,” IIUM Law Journal 23, no. 2 (2015): 289-308

Wook, Izzati. “Acknowledging Land Rights of The Orang Asli: A Historical Perspective of Laws in Peninsular Malaysia,” IIUM Law Journal 25, no. 1 (2017): 93-120, https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v25i1.309.