ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR) IN RESOLVING COMMUNITY DISPUTES IN PAKISTAN: LEARNING FROM MALAYSIA’S EXPERIENCE

Ihtesham Ullah Khan; Nurah Sabahiah Mohamed; Sodiq Omoola

doi:10.31436/iiumlj.v33i1.1029

Authors

Ihtesham Ullah Khan Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia
Nurah Sabahiah Mohamed Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia
Sodiq Omoola Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v33i1.1029

Keywords:

Traditional Dispute Resolution, Community Mediation, Human Rights Standards, Legal Framework

Abstract

Disputes are ubiquitous in human societies, spanning across individuals, families, tribes, and nations. In Pakistan, various provinces have developed traditional dispute resolution mechanisms: the Jirga system for the Pushtoon community, Panchayat for Punjabis, Faislo among Sindhis, and Balochi Jirga for Balochis. These systems, rooted in cultural practices, have historically facilitated justice and harmony. However, they have faced criticism for their reliance on unwritten rules, informal structures, and violations of human and women's rights. This article explores the nature of these traditional systems in Pakistan, analysing their methods of dispute resolution and their effectiveness in administering justice. The study adopts a qualitative methodology, using doctrinal and library-based legal research, along with a comparative analysis of community dispute resolution in Pakistan and Malaysia. It also proposes recommendations for enhancing these systems, drawing insights from Malaysia's successful community mediation programmes. Unlike Pakistan, Malaysia has formalised community mediation under the Department of National Unity and National Integration since 1969, achieving positive outcomes in dispute resolution. The article suggests that Pakistan should establish a legal framework to regulate community mediation, ensuring adherence to human rights and justice standards. By integrating lessons from Malaysia's approach and emphasising the role of government bodies in justice administration, the traditional dispute resolution systems in Pakistan can be strengthened for greater effectiveness and fairness in resolving disputes.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Abdullah, Asma, and Paul B. Pederson. Understanding Multicultural Malaysia: Delights, Puzzles, and Irritations. Selangor, Malaysia: Sdn. Bhd., 2003.

Ahmad, Muhammad Hassan, Ihtesham Ullah Khan, and Mohammad Naqib Ishan Jan. "Jirga and Dispute Resolution in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa: A Critical Analysis." Journal of Islamic Law Review 15, no. 1 (June 2019): 63-79.

Ahmad, Muhammad Hassan, and Ihtesham Ullah Khan. "A Legal Framework for the Jirga Community Mediation in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa." Islamic Law Review 3, no. 3 & 4 (Autumn/Winter 2019): 10-11.

Ambaras Khan, Nora Abdul Hak. Community Mediation in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka, 2018.

Ambaras Khan, Nora Abdul Hak. "Community Mediation in Malaysia: A Step Forward." Malayan Law Journal 1 (2014): 3. https://scholar.google.com (accessed April 12, 2025).

Ambaras Khan, Nora Abdul Hak. “Empowering Communities Through Mediation in Malaysia: Issues and Challenges.” Paper presented at the International Conference on Law and Society 1 (ICLAS 1) jointly organized by Faculties Hukum, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta and Harun M Hashim Law Centre, Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia, 2013.

Andaya, Barbara Watson, and Leonard Y. Andaya. A History of Malaysia. Macmillan: International Higher Education, 2016.

Ahmad, Sa’odah, Rojanah Kahar, and Muslihah Hasbullah, "Knowledge, Attitude and Practice of Community Mediators in Malaysia." Kajian Malaysia (early view 2021).

Barakatullah Advocate, and Imran Ahmad Sajid. "Jirga System in Pakhtun Society: An Informal Mechanism for Dispute Resolution." Pakistan Journal of Criminology 5, no. 2 (2013): 45-46.

Brown, Henry J., and Arthur L. Marriot Q.C. ADR Principles and Practice. 2nd ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1999.

Chaudhry, Abid Ghafoor, Aftab Ahmed, Shaheer Ellahi Khan, and Sajjad Hussain. "Perception of Local Community and Biradari on Panchayat: An Exploratory Anthropological Study of Biradari in Village Saroki, District Gujranwala, Pakistan." Advances in Anthropology 4, no. 2 (2014): 54.

Farooqi, Muhammad Rahmatullah, Haq Nawaz Anwar, and Falak Sher. "A Comparative Study of Panchayat System and State’s Judicial System in Punjab, Pakistan." Journal of Organizational Behaviour Research 4, no. 2 (2019): 142-149.

Ghafoor, Chaudhry Abid, Aftab Ahmed, Shaheer Ellahi Khan, and Sajjad Hussain. "Perception of Local Community and Biradari on Panchayat: An Exploratory Anthropological Study of Biradari in Village Saroki, District Gujranwala, Pakistan." Advances in Anthropology 4, no. 2 (2014): 54.

Gray, John, Moira Halliday, and Andrew Woodgate. Responding to Community Conflict. New York: York Publishing Services Ltd, 2002.

Heng, Pek K. Chinese Politics in Malaysia: A History of the Malaysian Chinese Association. Oxford University Press, 1988.

Ishan Jan, Mohammad Naqib, Ashgar Ali Ali Mohamed. Mediation in Malaysia: The Law and Practice. Selangor, Malaysia: LexisNexis Malaysia Sdn Bhd, 2010.

INITIATE.MY. "Policy Brief Launch and Webinar on ‘Mainstreaming Mediation as an Alternative Form of Conflict Resolution in Malaysia.’ Accessed April 15, 2025. https://initiate.my/event/policy-brief-launch-and- webinar-on-mainstreaming-mediation-as-an- alternative-form-of-conflict-resolution-in-malaysia/.

Khan, Hanna. "Mediation as a Means in Resolving Community Disputes in Peninsula Malaysia: A Historical Perspective." 2013. https://www.researchgate.net (accessed April 2, 2025).

Khan Hanna, Nora Abdul Hak. "Legal Framework and Structure of Community Mediation in Malaysia: A Proposal." Ph.D. thesis, International Islamic University Malaysia, 2017.

Khan, Nora Abdul Hak. "Comparison Between Community Mediation Program in Malaysia and Ireland: Some Lessons for Malaysia." In International Conference on Alternative Dispute Resolution 2017 Modern Trends and Effective Dispute Resolution, 80-81. Kuala Lumpur: Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia, 2017. (accessed March 16, 2025).

Khan, Ihtesham Ullah, Nurah Sabahiah, and Sodiq Omoola. "Legal Status and Future of Mediation in Pakistan: A Critical Exploration of ADR Frameworks." Journal of Law and Social Policy (2024): 17-18.

Marriot Q.C., Arthur L., and Henry J. Brown. ADR Principles and Practice. 2nd ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1999.

Muazzmi, Riaz Ahmad, and Aneela Sultana. "Ethnography of Panchayat: Cases of Khula from Mandi Baha-Ud-Din." Global Regional Review 5, no. 1 (2020): 76-83.

Nawaz, Allah. "Jirga and Panchayat as the Precursor to Honour Killing in Pakistan." Dialogue 15, no. 1 (2020): 105.

Rahmat, Nur Ezan, Daleleer Kaur Randawar, Aishah Mohd Nor, and Faridah Hussain. "Certification and Mediation Training for the Mediators in Malaysia." Malaysian Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities (MJSSH) 7, no. 11 (2022): 1–8.

Taizi, Sherzaman. Jirga System in Tribal Life. Peshawar: Area Study Centre, University of Peshawar, 2007.

The Dawn News Staff Reporter. "Panchayat Firing Death Toll Reaches Five." The Dawn News, April 14, 2023. https://www.dawn.com/news/1747468 (accessed April 5, 2025).

The Express Tribune Staff Reporter. "Nine Killed, 16 Injured in Clash During Jirga in Upper Dir." The Express Tribune, September 20, 2021. https://tribune.com.pk/story/2321086/nine-killed-16-injured-in-clash-during-jirga-in-upper-dir (accessed April 5, 2025).

Wardak, Ali. "Jirga—A Traditional Mechanism of Conflict Resolution in Afghanistan." Institute of Afghan Study Centre, 2003.

Yen, Ching-Hwang. The Chinese in Southeast Asia and Beyond: Socioeconomic and Political Dimensions. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd, 2008.

Zhang, Yang. "Mediation Model Differences Between China and Australia and Their Possible Collaboration." Journal of Interdisciplinary Conflict Science 1, no. 1 (2015): 46-58.