SHARIAH’S POSITION IN AFGHAN 2004 CONSTITUTION: A LEGAL ANALYSIS

Muhibullah Faizan; Noor Shuhadawati Mohamad Amin; Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohammad

doi:10.31436/iiumlj.v32i2.1004

Authors

Muhibullah Faizan Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia
Noor Shuhadawati Mohamad Amin Ahmad Ibrahim Kulliyyah of Laws, International Islamic University Malaysia
Mohammad Tahir Sabit Haji Mohammad Shariah Faculty, Afghan International Islamic University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31436/iiumlj.v32i2.1004

Keywords:

Afghanistan, Shariah, Basic Law, Article 3, Ambiguity

Abstract

The legal position of Shariah in the 2004 Afghan constitution has been considerably debated due to the full involvement of the international community in the constitution-making process. Though Article 3 of the 2004 constitution of Afghanistan states that “no law shall contravene the beliefs and principles of Islam”, considering this provision and others, the position of Shariah in the constitution seems ambiguous. Some legal experts at national and international levels consider the 2004 constitution to be one of the most Islamic constitutions, recognising the supremacy of Shariah. Contrary to this, some scholars think that a set of constitutional provisions predicate a limited applicability of Shariah by referring to Hanafi Fiqh as a gap-filling law in Article 130. Keeping this problem in mind, this research paper examines the supremacy of Shariah in light of all provisions in the 2004 constitution. It aims to outline the actual role of Shariah within the 2004 constitution by elaborating on the different concepts of Shariah and law in the Afghan legal system. The study which follows qualitative research methodology is conducted through major library research and an empirical study, employing comparative and analytical approaches per doctrinal and non-doctrinal methods. It exposes the conceptual and applied aspects of the legal provisions relating to the applicability of the Shariah in the 2004 constitution. The research generally relied on primary sources such as the constitution of Afghanistan and the Quran and Sunnah for the Shariah. The researcher considered the connection between the various constitutional provisions on Shariah in conjunction with the hierarchy of legal norms and found that Shariah has a weak position under the 2004 constitutional setup up as a judicial review attests. The 2004 constitution provides a limited applicability of Shariah in the sense that no law shall contravene the Shariah while at the same time, the term law does not include the constitution- itself and the term Shariah generally refers to Hanafi Fiqh as a subsidiary source of law. The constitutional provisions on Shariah are not amendable, as the 2004 constitution declares them irrevocable. To strengthen the position of Shariah, it is proposed that the primary step is to define the term law comprehensively to include the constitution. However, the best alternative is that Afghans enact a new constitution that provides the supremacy of Shariah.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Ahmadi, Mohammad Nader. “Jaiga, Ahamiat wa Zarorat Afta[ The Position, Importance and necessity of Announce a Religious Opinion].” The supreme court publisher center ( 2011): 90.

Al-Ansari, Salah. "Contextualising Islamic Criminal Law: An Analysis of Al-Azhar Scholars' Contributions." Manchester Journal of Transnational Islamic Law & Practice 19, no. 2 (2023):20-22.

Alekseyeva, Kristina. et al. An Introduction to the Laws of Afghanistan. Afghanistan Legal Education Project, 2017.

Al-Hafizh, Rasyid, Fachrul Rozy and Zaim Rais. "Usul Al-Fiqh: Its Epistemology, Purpose, and Use." DIKTUM: Jurnal Syariah Dan Hukum 19 (2021): 1-15

Allama, Ghalam Hedar. “Aieen Dad Rasi Kefari Afghanistan [ code of criminal procedure in Afghanistan].” The Judiciary Law Journal 71. n, 60 (2007): 42.

Amini, Kaiwana. "Investigating the Implementation of the Rules of Islamic Criminal Law in Afghanistan." Integrated Journal for Research in Arts and Humanities 4, no. 5 (2024): 71-76.

Azimi, Abdul Salam, Baha-U-deen Baha and Abdul Karim Qanit. Presentation of Paper of Article 130 in the constitution of Afghanistan. Kabul: 2020.

Barr, Heather, and Joseph Saunders. " I Had to Run Away": The Imprisonment of Women and Girls for moral Crimes." in Afghanistan. Human rights watch (HRW), 2012.

Danish, Sarwar. Haqoqi Asasi Afghanistan [ Constitutional law of Afghanistan] Publisher of Ibn Sina Institute, 2010.

Ebeku, Kaniye S. A. “The limited applicability of Shariah under the constitution of Nigeria.” in The Book by Design: Constitutionalism in

Islamic Countries:Between Upheaval and Continuity, edited by Rainer Grote and Tilmann J. Roder. Oxford University Press, 2012.

Fields, Mark, and Ramsha Ahmed. A review of the 2001 Bonn Conference and application to the road ahead in Afghanistan. National Defense University Press, 2011.

Gray, Tallyn. Islam and International Criminal Law and Justice. Torkal Opsahl Academic EPublisher, 2018.

Habibi, Abdul Hai. A Short History of Afghanistan. Book Publishing Institution with Cooperation by the Historical Society of Afghanistan, 1961.

Hall, Daniel E. Criminal Law and Procedure. Example Product Manufacturer, 6th ed, 2011.

Hashimi, Ghazi. “Defending the Principle of Legality in Afghanistan: Toward a Unified Interpretation of Article 130 to the Afghan Constitution.” p 4 (accessed 25 October, 2024).

Hilali, Sad al-Din Musad. Al-maharat al-usuliyyah Wa Atharuha Fi al-nudj Wa al-tajdid al-fiqhi. Majlis al-nashr al-ilmi, 2004.

Human Rights Watch. Free Women Jailed for "Running Away", (2012) <http://www.refworld.org/docid/505c1c852.html > (accessed 4 November, 2024).

Ibn Sad, Muhammad. Al-Tabaqat al-Kubra. Beirut, 1957.

Kamali, Mohammad Hashim. "References to Islam and women in the Afghan constitution." Arab Law Quarterly 22, no. 3 (2008): 270-306.

Kamali, Mohammad Hashim. “Afghanistan’s Constitution 2004: An Islamic Perspective on Interpretation.” USIP Paper 2008), 4-6.

Kamel, Taymour. The Principle of Legality and Its Application in Islamic Criminal Justice System. M. Cherif Bassiouni, 1982.

Kayadibi, Saim. Principle of Islamic Law, The Methods of Interpretation of the Text, Usul al-Fiqh. Islamic Book Trust, 2018.

Khaama Press, “Sellers of dog meat jailed for 13 years in Herat province (2015) <https://www.khaama.com/sellers-of-dog-meat-jailed-for-13-years-in-herat-province-8950 > ( accessed 25 October, 2024). And see more Primary Court of Herat City, Selling Dog Meat case, PP 40–48. `And also indictment of the prosecutor, PP 1-2.

Khaama Press, “Individuals arrested for selling dog meat in Herat province”, ( 2014) <https://www.khaama.com/individuals-arrested-for-selling-dog-meat-in-herat-province-8816> ( accessed 24 October, 2024).

Khana-e-Wiristayi Afghanistan. Sharhi Kode Jaza [Explanation of 2017 Penal Code]. Asia Foundation, 2019.

Laldin, Mohammad Akram. Islamic Law An Introduction. IIUM Press, 2021.

Laly, Maryam. "The Women’s Rights Movement in Afghanistan: The Absence of Scholarship and the Challenges of Practice." The Pi Sigma Alpha Undergraduate Journal of Politics (2015): 51.

Lue, Martin, “Islamic Law in the Legal System of Afghanistan.” in the Bonn symposium on the State Reconstruction and International Engagement in Afghanistan 2003 organised by London School of Economics and Political Science and University of Bonn. (accessed 22 October, 2024).

Masoudi, Majid, Seyyed Ebrahim Hoseini, and Zabihullah Moradi. "Evaluation of Mechanisms for Ensuring Women's Religious Identity from the Perspective of Jurisprudence and Legal System in Afghanistan." Journal of the Socio-Political Thought of Islam 3, no. 2 (2024): 41-58.

Max Planck Foundation for international Peace and the Rule of Law & Afghanistan Legal Research and Development Organization, Constitutional Law and Human Rights International, Comparative and National Perspective. Amiri Publisher, 2020.

Meirison, Meirison. et al. "An Application Study on Taklifi Law: Fiqh Schools (Madhab) Perspective." Hunafa: Jurnal Studia Islamika 18, no. 2 (2021): 195-214.

Mohammad Qasim Hashimzai. “The separation of Powers and the Problem of Constitutional Interpretation in Afghanistan.” in The Book by Design: Constitutionalism in Islamic Countries:Between Upheaval and Continuity, edited by Rainer Grote and Tilmann J. Roder.

Oxford University Press, 2012.

Moschtaghi, Ramin S. “Constitutionalism in an Islamic Republic the Principle of the Afghan Constitution and the Conflict between them.” in The Book by Design: in Constitutionalism in Islamic Countries: Between Upheaval and Continuity, edited by Rainer Grote and Tilmann J. Roder. Oxford University Press, 2012.

Muneer, Kuttiyani Muhammed, and Mumtaz Ali Muhammad. "The Shariah and Law: An Analysis." International Journal of Law, Government and Communication 2, no. 5 (2017).

Nikpay, Sana Matin. Tahlil Takhasosi Qanone Asasi Afghanistan [The Professional Analysis of the Constitution of the Afghanistan]. athenaeum, 2018.

Oates, Lauryn. "A Closer Look: The policy and law-making process behind the Shiite Personal Status Law." (2009): 1-31.

Popal, Mahmood, and Seid Mahdi Seidzadeh. "Impressive Factors of the Victimization of Shiite Muslim Minorities in Afghanistan: A Case Study District 13 of Kabul during the Pre-Taliban Period." International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology (2024): 0306624X241281970.

Rasekh, Mohammad. “Non-Violation of Islamic Law under the Afghan Constitution.” Journal of Afghan Legal Studies 2, no.2 (2017):198.

Rasooli, Mohammad Ashraf, Mr. Ruhullah Qarizada, DR Ahmad Raza Sadeqe. Presentation of Paper of Article 130 in the constitution of Afghanistan. Kabul, 2020.

Rasooli, Mohammad Ashraf. Mahakima-Ye Adilana [ Fair Trail]. Saed Publication, 2014.

Rasooli, Mohammad Ashraf. Tahlil wa Naqd Qanoni Asasi Afghanistan [The Analysis and Criticism of the Constitution of the Afghanistan]. Sead Publisher, 2012.

Rubin, Barnett R. Constitutional Issues in the Afghan Peace Negotiations: Process and Substance. United States Institute of Peace., 2020.

Saeed, Lutforahman. "Analysis of Article 130 of the Afghan Constitution." Islam, Custom and Human Rights: A Legal and Empirical

Study of Criminal Cases in Afghanistan After the 2004 Constitution (2022): 65-78.

Saeed, Lutforahman. "Legal Pluralism in Afghanistan." Islam, Custom and Human Rights: A Legal and Empirical Study of Criminal

Cases in Afghanistan After the 2004 Constitution (2022): 23-64.

Thier, J. Alexander. " The Making of a Constitution in Afghanistan." New York Law School 51 (2006): 557.

Tuohid Khaneh, Mohammad Sadr. “Atebar Asal Qanoni Bodan Dar Haqoqi Kaifari Afghanistan: Moshkil Wa Rah Hal Karha[ The validity of the principle of legality in the Afghan criminal law: Problems and the way for solutions].” Journal of Criminal Law 5. no, 17 (2017):157-195.